Select your language

Landmark shift in case law on the assessment of whether an exclusion clause is "explicit and limited"

Article L.113-1 of the French Insurance Code provides that an exclusion clause is valid only if it is "explicit and limited" (formelle et limitée).

Until now, French case law could result in an exclusion clause being invalidated in its entirety where some of the grounds for exclusion it contained were not sufficiently clear (Civ. 2e, 17 June 2021, No 19-24.467, published).

In this decision, the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) introduces a significant departure from its previous case law regarding the assessment of whether an exclusion clause is sufficiently explicit.

The Court first reiterates that "an exclusion clause does not meet the requirement of clarity within the meaning of this provision where it does not refer to precise criteria and requires interpretation".

It then holds that:

"The approach of invalidating only those exclusions within a single clause that do not meet the requirement of clarity, while preserving those that do, strikes a balance between, on the one hand, the objective of protecting the insured and, on the other hand, the insurer's economic expectations and the interests of the insured community as a whole."

Ultimately, the Court concludes that "the invalidity of an exclusion that does not meet the requirement of clarity does not entail the invalidity of the entire clause, unless it affects the interpretation of that clause".

This landmark shift in case law arises, in particular, against the backdrop of the extensive litigation stemming from COVID-19-related insurance claims. However, its implications extend well beyond such disputes: the ruling is intended to apply to all insurance contracts governed by Article L.113-1 of the French Insurance Code.

Civ. 2e, 17 September 2026, No 25-12.441 

 

Written by Géraud de Puget